154 Highlights 54 Differences 8 Reactions 0 Likes

Proton vs Private Internet Access: 154 Highlights & 54 Differences — So, Which VPN Actually Works Better

Discover OS compatibility details. Find the best VPN for your devices. We compared Proton and Private Internet Access for people who care about intended use, target user, account sharing policy & deployment type and time-saving tools. Here’s what to know before committing.

76 Points
Proton
Proton
Proton
Proton
61 Points
Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access
vs

Highlights 175

No extras. Just what matters.
76 Points
vs
61 Points

Why is Proton better than Private Internet Access ?

Scroll down for more facts

Proton VPN vs Private Internet Access: Which VPN Fits Your Privacy Needs Better?

When it comes to choosing between Proton VPN and Private Internet Access (PIA), both services cater to privacy-conscious individuals with overlapping features that focus on security, streaming capabilities, and P2P support. Each VPN offers no-logs policies, third-party audits, and kill switches

Yet, some key distinctions set them apart, particularly in regulatory compliance, network architecture, streaming reliability, and platform support. Proton VPN boasts full server ownership and GDPR compliance, while PIA offers more flexible encryption algorithms and Smart TV compatibility.

The Strengths of Proton VPN: Privacy Meets Business-Ready Versatility

Proton VPN stands out for users who seek strong regulatory compliance with GDPR alongside robust server ownership by operating entirely on its own infrastructure. This ensures tighter control over user data and greater trust in privacy safeguards. With a superior peak speed of 900 Mbps and smart routing capabilities, Proton VPN optimizes connections for speed and reliability across regions, which translates into smoother streaming and P2P experiences. Its support for multiple user types, including business clients, makes it particularly versatile.

Moreover, Proton VPN provides helpful usability features such as browser extensions and transparency with login history and session management. It also supports an extensive range of operating systems and devices, including CLI access for advanced users. Streaming aficionados will appreciate Proton's high reliability with major platforms like Netflix, Amazon Prime Video, and Disney+.

Private Internet Access: Customizable Security and Expanded Device Compatibility

PIA shines with its emphasis on customization, offering a trio of encryption key exchange methods (RSA, ECDHE, IKEv2) that appeal to users needing specific security protocols. While it does not boast smart routing, it compensates with unique features like automation scripts and custom DNS settings, providing extra control for power users.

A major perk for media enthusiasts is PIA's support for Smart TVs, a convenience that Proton VPN currently does not offer. In addition, PIA fosters community engagement through a dedicated community forum, where users can share experiences and seek peer advice, enhancing the support ecosystem beyond live chat and email. Its streaming compatibility includes popular services like Netflix, Hulu, Disney+, and Amazon Prime Video, although streaming reliability is rated moderate compared to Proton's higher marks.

Quick Take

For those prioritizing regulatory compliance, owned infrastructure, and top-tier streaming reliability, Proton VPN hits the mark with its business-friendly approach and advanced speed optimizations. In contrast, Private Internet Access appeals to users who value customizable security options, Smart TV support, and an engaged community forum, paired with solid, but slightly lower, streaming performance.

Bottom Line

Choosing between Proton VPN and Private Internet Access boils down to what matters most to you: seek Proton VPN for a service thriving on transparency, GDPR compliance, and superior streaming and speed benefits, especially for families or businesses. Opt for Private Internet Access if you want greater encryption flexibility, Smart TV compatibility, and active user communities, especially if you are an individual user focused on personalization.

Verdict

  • Winner: Proton VPN - It wins thanks to its full server ownership, GDPR compliance, smart routing for optimized speed, strong streaming performance, and broad applicability, including business use.
  • Runner-up: Private Internet Access - A compelling option for individuals wanting customizable encryption, automation, and Smart TV support, despite lacking smart routing or free trials.

Comparisons 32

Two enter. One leaves your cart.

Price comparisons

(✱) Prices may be changed at any time without further notice.

Related comparisons 32

Because one duel is never enough.

Comparisons & Facts 175

Side by side. The numbers. The features. No drama.

Tired of marketing fluff? This data-backed comparison of Proton vs Private Internet Access tells you what works — and what doesn’t — for your next vpn.

General Information 12

Target User

Who is this VPN designed for?

68 Proton 0 Votes Individual, Family, Team, Business

26 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Individual

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Target User

Proton serves a broad target user base including Individual, Family, Team, and Business users, while Private Internet Access is designed primarily for Individual users. Proton is more suitable for diverse user groups needing flexible VPN solutions.

Identifies the primary audience.

Account Sharing Policy

Is account sharing allowed?

47 Proton 0 Votes Restricted

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Restricted

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Account sharing is restricted, which helps to maintain service integrity and fair usage.

Defines rules around sharing accounts.

Deployment Type

What is the deployment type?

87 Proton 0 Votes Cloud-Based

36 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Cloud-Based

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Deployment Type

Both Proton and Private Internet Access utilize Cloud-Based deployment types, ensuring scalable and easily accessible VPN services.

How the VPN infrastructure is deployed and managed.

Intended Use

What is this VPN mainly used for?

56 Proton 0 Votes Privacy, Security, Streaming, P2P, Business

0 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Privacy, Security, Streaming, P2P

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Intended Use

Proton offers VPN services for Privacy, Security, Streaming, P2P, and Business use, whereas Private Internet Access supports Privacy, Security, Streaming, and P2P only. Proton is better suited for business-related VPN needs.

Describes the main use cases supported.

VPN Service Type

What type of VPN service is offered?

57 Proton 0 Votes Consumer VPN,Business VPN,Enterprise VPN

16 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Consumer VPN

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Designed as a consumer VPN, it targets personal users focused on privacy, security, and streaming use cases.

Indicates the primary service classification.

Platform Category

Which platform categories are supported?

71 Proton 0 Votes Desktop, Mobile, Browser, Router

64 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Desktop, Mobile, Browser, Smart TV, Router

Proton
Proton

Supports multiple platforms including desktop, mobile devices, browsers, and routers, offering versatile usage across different environments.

Indicates supported platform categories.

Simultaneous Connections

How many simultaneous connections are allowed?

57 Proton 0 Votes 8–10 Connections

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Unlimited

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

The service permits an unlimited number of simultaneous connections, ideal for users with multiple devices.

Number of devices that can connect at the same time.

Regulatory Compliance Statement

What regulations does it comply with?

87 Proton 1 Votes GDPR

0 Private Internet Access 0 Votes None

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Regulatory Compliance Statement

Proton complies with GDPR regulations, but Private Internet Access lacks a regulatory compliance statement. For users prioritizing regulatory compliance, Proton is the preferable choice.

Stated compliance with data protection regulations.

I really appreciate Proton's GDPR compliance as it gives me peace of mind about privacy. It feels more trustworthy compared to PIA’s lack of regulatory compliance.

See more

Release Year

When was this VPN first released?

86 Proton 0 Votes 2017

36 Private Internet Access 0 Votes 2010

Year the VPN service was first released.

Service Model

What service model does the VPN use?

57 Proton 0 Votes Freemium

36 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Subscription-Based

Business and access model used to provide the VPN service.

Supported Devices Count

How many devices are supported?

67 Proton 0 Votes 7–10 Devices

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Unlimited Devices

Maximum number of devices supported per account.

Service Availability

Where is the service available?

97 Proton 0 Votes Global

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Global

Geographic scope where the VPN service is available.

Security & Encryption 24

Kill Switch

Is a kill switch available?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Kill Switch

Both Proton and Private Internet Access include a Kill Switch feature, which safeguards user privacy by disconnecting internet in case of VPN failure.

Blocks traffic if VPN connection drops.

Third-Party Audit Availability

Are third-party audits available?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Third-Party Audit Availability

Both Proton and Private Internet Access provide Third-Party Audit Availability, reflecting strong transparency and security assurance in their services.

Availability of external audit reports.

Key Exchange Method

How are encryption keys exchanged?

86 Proton 0 Votes ECDHE

64 Private Internet Access 0 Votes RSA, ECDHE, IKEv2

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Key Exchange Method

Proton employs ECDHE for key exchange, while Private Internet Access supports RSA, ECDHE, and IKEv2 methods. Private Internet Access offers more key exchange options, catering to diverse security preferences.

Describes how encryption keys are securely exchanged.

Stealth Mode

Is stealth mode available?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Stealth Mode

Stealth Mode is available on both Proton and Private Internet Access, enhancing the users' ability to avoid VPN detection effectively.

Hides VPN usage from detection systems.

Audit Frequency

How often are audits done?

76 Proton 0 Votes Periodic

85 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Periodic

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Audit Frequency

Proton and Private Internet Access both perform periodic security audits, underlining their commitment to maintaining secure VPN environments.

How often audits are performed.

Encryption Standard

What encryption standard is used?

72 Proton 0 Votes AES, ChaCha20

26 Private Internet Access 0 Votes AES

Proton
Proton

Encryption standards used are AES and ChaCha20, both of which are considered highly secure and reliable for protecting data.

Specifies the primary encryption algorithms used.

Perfect Forward Secrecy

Is perfect forward secrecy supported?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Perfect Forward Secrecy is implemented, improving cryptographic security by regularly changing encryption keys.

Ensures past sessions remain secure if keys are compromised.

VPN Protocols Supported

Which VPN protocols are supported?

82 Proton 0 Votes OpenVPN, WireGuard

61 Private Internet Access 0 Votes OpenVPN, WireGuard

Proton
Proton

Supports multiple VPN protocols including OpenVPN and WireGuard, catering to different user needs for security and compatibility.

Lists all supported VPN protocols.

Default Protocol

What protocol is used by default?

97 Proton 0 Votes WireGuard

76 Private Internet Access 0 Votes WireGuard

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

WireGuard is the default protocol, offering a modern, fast, and secure VPN connection experience.

Protocol used by default.

Security Audits Conducted

Have security audits been conducted?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Security audits have been conducted, providing additional assurance about the robustness of the VPN's protections.

Indicates if audits have been performed.

Encryption Strength

What encryption strength is used?

90 Proton 0 Votes AES-256,ChaCha20

46 Private Internet Access 0 Votes AES-128,AES-256

Level and type of encryption used to secure data.

Authentication Method

How are VPN connections authenticated?

96 Proton 0 Votes Certificates

56 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Certificates, Pre-Shared Key

Method used to authenticate connections.

Privacy & Logging Policy 18

RAM-Only Servers

Are RAM-only servers used?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
RAM-Only Servers

RAM-Only Servers are utilized by both Proton and Private Internet Access. This ensures that no data is permanently stored on physical servers, enhancing privacy and security.

Indicates use of volatile memory servers.

Logging Policy Type

What is the logging policy type?

97 Proton 0 Votes No-Logs

36 Private Internet Access 0 Votes No-Logs

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Logging Policy Type

Both Proton and Private Internet Access follow a No-Logs policy type, ensuring that user activity data is not recorded, which is crucial for privacy-conscious users.

Describes the overall logging stance.

Connection Logs

Are connection logs stored?

No 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Connection Logs

Neither Proton nor Private Internet Access logs connection data, supporting user anonymity and privacy effectively.

Indicates logging of connection metadata.

Metadata Logs

Are metadata logs collected?

No 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Metadata Logs

Neither Proton nor Private Internet Access logs metadata, which further protects users from activity tracking and potential data leaks.

Indicates logging of metadata beyond traffic.

User Data Deletion Policy

Can users delete their data?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
User Data Deletion Policy

Both Proton and Private Internet Access have user data deletion policies, ensuring users can request removal of their personal data, a key element for privacy compliance.

Indicates if users can request data deletion.

Data Retention Period

How long is data retained?

97 Proton 0 Votes No Logs

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes No Logs

Proton
Proton

This VPN follows a strict no-logs policy, meaning it does not store any user activity or connection data, enhancing privacy.

Length of time user data is retained.

Privacy Policy Clarity

How clear is the privacy policy?

97 Proton 0 Votes Clear

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Clear

Proton
Proton

The privacy policy is clear, providing transparency and easy understanding of data handling procedures.

Describes how understandable the policy is.

Activity Logs

Are activity logs stored?

No 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates whether user activity is logged.

IP Address Logging

Are IP addresses logged?

No 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates whether IP addresses are logged.

Timestamp Logging

Are timestamps logged?

No 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates logging of session timestamps.

Bandwidth Usage Logging

Is bandwidth usage logged?

No 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates logging of bandwidth usage.

Jurisdiction Country

Which country is the jurisdiction?

77 Proton 0 Votes Switzerland

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes United States

Country where the VPN company is legally registered.

Network & Server Infrastructure 20

Throttling Policy

Is bandwidth throttled?

17 Proton 0 Votes No Throttling

0 Private Internet Access 0 Votes No Throttling

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Throttling Policy

Both Proton and Private Internet Access adopt a No Throttling policy, ensuring users enjoy unrestricted bandwidth without speed reduction.

Describes bandwidth throttling rules.

Data Center Tier

What data center tier is used?

47 Proton 0 Votes Tier III

85 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Tier III

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Data Center Tier

Both Proton and Private Internet Access utilize Tier III data centers, offering high availability and redundancy for reliable VPN service.

Indicates data center reliability level.

Gaming Optimized Servers

Are gaming servers available?

No 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Gaming Optimized Servers

Neither Proton nor Private Internet Access offer gaming optimized servers, meaning gamers may not find specialized routing or infrastructure for gaming in either service.

Servers optimized for low-latency gaming.

Total Server Count

How many servers are available?

97 Proton 0 Votes 3000+

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes 3000+

Proton
Proton

This VPN offers a large network with more than 3000+ servers, providing extensive options for connectivity and optimal performance.

Approximate total number of servers available.

Total Country Coverage

How many countries are covered?

97 Proton 0 Votes 90+

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes 90+

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

The VPN service covers over 90 countries, providing extensive global server options for diversified and reliable connectivity.

Number of countries with server presence.

Total City Coverage

How many cities are covered?

77 Proton 0 Votes 100–200

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes 200+

Proton
Proton

Coverage spans 100–200 cities worldwide, giving users extensive choices for regional connections.

Number of cities with VPN servers.

Server Location Type

Are server locations physical or virtual?

97 Proton 0 Votes Mixed

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Mixed

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Server locations include both physical and virtual types, providing a flexible infrastructure designed for performance and coverage.

Indicates how server locations are implemented.

Bandwidth Capacity

What is the bandwidth capacity?

97 Proton 0 Votes Unlimited

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Unlimited

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Bandwidth Capacity

Bandwidth capacity is unlimited on both Proton and Private Internet Access, allowing unrestricted data usage suitable for heavy VPN users.

Overall bandwidth capability of the network.

Network Uptime SLA

Is there an uptime SLA?

64 Proton 0 Votes 99.9%

0 Private Internet Access 0 Votes No SLA

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

There is no uptime Service Level Agreement (SLA) provided, indicating no formal guarantees on network availability.

Guaranteed network uptime level.

Server Status Transparency

Is server status transparent?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
Proton

Server status transparency allows users to view real-time server availability and performance metrics.

Indicates public server status visibility.

Server Ownership

Who owns the servers?

87 Proton 1 Votes Owned

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Hybrid

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Server Ownership

Proton owns its servers whereas Private Internet Access operates a hybrid server ownership model. Proton's full ownership provides tighter control over infrastructure security.

Describes who controls the servers.

Proton owning its servers outright is a huge plus for me since it means better control over data security. PIA's hybrid ownership feels less solid on that front.

See more

Load Balancing

Is load balancing supported?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Distributes traffic evenly across servers.

Performance & Speed 14

Latency Impact

How much latency does the VPN add?

15 ms 0 Votes
Proton
15 ms 0 Votes
Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Latency Impact

Both Proton and Private Internet Access exhibit the same latency impact of 15 milliseconds, indicating similar network responsiveness and low delay.

Additional latency introduced by the VPN.

Smart Routing

Is smart routing used?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Smart Routing

Proton supports Smart Routing to optimize traffic for performance, while Private Internet Access does not have this feature. Proton is better suited for users seeking intelligent data routing.

Routes traffic through optimal paths.

Regional Speed Optimization

Is regional speed optimization supported?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Regional Speed Optimization

Both Proton and Private Internet Access feature Regional Speed Optimization, improving connection speeds based on geographical locations, resulting in enhanced user performance.

Optimizes speeds by geographic region.

Performance Analytics

Are performance analytics available?

No 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Performance Analytics

Neither Proton nor Private Internet Access provide Performance Analytics, so users cannot access detailed VPN performance metrics from these services.

Provides performance monitoring insights.

Average Upload Speed

What is the average upload speed?

250 Mbps 0 Votes
Proton
300 Mbps 0 Votes
Private Internet Access

Proton
Proton

The average upload speed is around 250 Mbps, sufficient for smooth video calls, gaming, and file uploading.

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Average upload speed reaches 300 Mbps, allowing fast data sending capabilities useful for activities like live streaming and large file uploads.

Typical upstream speed when using the VPN.

Average Download Speed

What is the average download speed?

300 Mbps 0 Votes
Proton
350 Mbps 0 Votes
Private Internet Access

Proton
Proton

The average download speed is approximately 300 Mbps, sufficient for demanding tasks like HD streaming and gaming.

Typical downstream speed when connected to the VPN.

Speed Consistency

How consistent are the speeds?

97 Proton 0 Votes High

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes High

Proton
Proton

Speed consistency is high, meaning users experience stable speeds without significant fluctuations during use.

Stability of speeds over time.

Protocol Speed Optimization

Are protocols optimized for speed?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

The VPN supports protocol speed optimization to enhance the efficiency and speed of the connection.

Optimizes protocol choice for speed.

Speed Test Tool

Is there a built-in speed test?

No 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Speed Test Tool is available, allowing users to measure and monitor their VPN connection performance easily.

Built-in tool for measuring VPN speed.

Peak Speed Performance

What is the peak speed performance?

900 Mbps 1 Votes
Proton
800 Mbps 0 Votes
Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Peak Speed Performance

Proton offers a higher peak speed performance of 900 Mbps compared to Private Internet Access's 800 Mbps, making Proton more suitable for bandwidth-intensive activities.

Maximum achievable speed under ideal conditions.

The peak speed of 900 Mbps with Proton is pretty impressive especially for streaming and gaming. PIA is good but lags a bit behind with 800 Mbps.

See more

Speed Throttling

Is speed throttling applied?

No 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates whether speeds are artificially limited.

Auto Server Selection Speed

Does it auto-select the fastest server?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Automatically selects fastest servers.

Platform & Device Support 13

OS Version Compatibility

Which OS versions are supported?

86 Proton 0 Votes Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android

75 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, Android

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
OS Version Compatibility

OS compatibility is identical for Proton and Private Internet Access, supporting Windows, macOS, Linux, iOS, and Android, thus facilitating wide platform support.

Operating systems and platforms supported.

Browser Extension

Are browser extensions available?

Yes 1 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Browser Extension

Proton offers browser extensions, yet Private Internet Access does not. Browser extensions add convenience, so Proton is more user-friendly for browser-based VPN usage.

Indicates availability of browser extensions.

Browser extensions are super convenient and Proton has them while PIA doesn’t. That’s a key feature I use daily for easy VPN access.

See more

Smart TV

Are smart TVs supported?

No 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Smart TV

Private Internet Access supports Smart TV platforms, whereas Proton does not, making Private Internet Access preferable for users wanting VPN on Smart TVs.

Indicates support for smart TV platforms.

CLI Support

Is CLI support available?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
CLI Support

Both Proton and Private Internet Access support Command Line Interface (CLI) tools, catering to users who prefer advanced VPN control and scripting.

Indicates command-line interface availability.

IoT Device Compatibility

Are IoT devices compatible?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
IoT Device Compatibility

Both Proton and Private Internet Access support IoT device compatibility, enabling VPN protection on connected smart home devices.

Indicates compatibility with IoT devices.

Browser Types Supported

Which browsers are supported?

91 Proton 0 Votes Chrome, Firefox

75 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Chrome, Firefox, Edge, Opera

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Browser support extends to major types including Chrome, Firefox, Edge, and Opera, ensuring flexibility for users across different platforms.

Lists supported browser types.

ARM Architecture

Are ARM devices supported?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

ARM architecture support is enabled, indicating compatibility with ARM-based devices which often deliver efficient performance and lower power consumption.

Indicates support for ARM-based devices.

Gaming Console

Are gaming consoles supported?

No 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates compatibility with gaming consoles.

Manual Configuration

Is manual configuration supported?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Allows manual VPN setup.

App Interface Consistency

Is the app interface consistent?

97 Proton 0 Votes Consistent

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Consistent

Consistency of UI across platforms.

Cross-Platform Sync

Is cross-platform sync available?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Syncs settings across devices.

Device Management Dashboard

Is there a device management dashboard?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Centralized device management interface.

Features & Functionality 24

Automation Scripts

Are automation scripts supported?

No 0 Votes Proton

Yes 1 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
vs
Private Internet Access
Automation Scripts

Private Internet Access enables Automation Scripts while Proton does not, providing more options for automation and customization to advanced users in Private Internet Access.

Allows use of automation scripts.

PIA offering automation scripts is a neat feature for power users like me who want to customize the VPN experience. Proton just doesn’t have that.

See more

Custom DNS

Can custom DNS be configured?

No 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Allows use of custom DNS resolvers.

Mesh Networking

Is mesh networking supported?

No 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Connects devices in a private mesh network.

Per-App Rules

Can rules be set per app?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Applies VPN rules per application.

App-Based Split Tunneling

Can split tunneling be set per app?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
Proton

Supports app-based split tunneling, enabling users to select which applications use the VPN connection and which do not.

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

App-Based Split Tunneling is supported, allowing users to route specific apps outside the VPN for tailored connectivity.

Allows split tunneling by application.

Port Forwarding

Is port forwarding supported?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
Proton

Port forwarding capabilities are supported, allowing remote access setups and improved P2P performance.

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Port Forwarding is supported, which can improve connectivity for specific apps like torrents or gaming.

Enables inbound connections through the VPN.

Feature Customization Depth

How customizable are the features?

87 Proton 0 Votes Advanced

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Advanced

Proton
Proton

Feature customization depth is advanced, allowing users to finely tune settings to suit their security and performance needs.

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Feature customization is advanced, allowing users to tailor the VPN functionalities to their specific needs.

Describes overall customization level.

Split Tunneling

Is split tunneling supported?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Split tunneling is supported, enabling users to selectively route traffic inside or outside the VPN, optimizing bandwidth and performance.

Allows selective routing of traffic outside the VPN.

Tracker Blocker

Are trackers blocked?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Tracker Blocker is included, enhancing privacy by blocking tracking attempts from websites and advertisers.

Blocks tracking scripts and domains.

Malware Protection

Is malware protection included?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Proton
Proton

Malware protection is integrated to protect users from malicious websites and downloads while connected.

Protects against malicious domains.

Smart DNS

Is Smart DNS supported?

No 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Smart DNS feature is included to provide faster streaming capabilities without encrypting all traffic.

Enables DNS-based unblocking without encryption.

URL-Based Split Tunneling

Can split tunneling be set by URL?

No 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Allows split tunneling by website or domain.

Streaming, Gaming & P2P Support 9

Streaming Reliability

How reliable is streaming access?

97 Proton 0 Votes High

26 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Moderate

Proton
Proton

Streaming reliability is high, ensuring stable and consistent delivery of streaming services with minimal interruptions.

Consistency of streaming access over time.

Torrenting Policy

Is torrenting allowed?

97 Proton 0 Votes Allowed

36 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Allowed

Proton
Proton

Torrenting is permitted, enabling peer-to-peer file sharing with appropriate privacy protections.

Defines torrenting rules.

Streaming Platform Support

Which streaming platforms are supported?

92 Proton 1 Votes Netflix, Amazon Prime Video, Disney+

77 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Netflix, Hulu, Disney+, Amazon Prime Video

Streaming platforms that the VPN can reliably unblock and support.

I prefer Proton for streaming because it includes Netflix, Amazon Prime, and Disney+ with high reliability. PIA supports more platforms but isn’t as reliable streaming-wise.

See more

4K Streaming

Is 4K streaming supported?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates support for 4K streaming quality.

Cloud Gaming

Does it support cloud gaming?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates compatibility with cloud gaming services.

Port Selection for P2P

Can ports be selected for P2P?

No 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Port selection for P2P is supported, allowing users to enhance peer-to-peer sharing performance and security.

Allows port selection for P2P traffic.

HD Streaming

Is HD streaming supported?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates support for HD streaming quality.

Gaming Latency Optimization

Is gaming latency optimized?

No 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Optimizes routing for low gaming latency.

P2P File Sharing

Is P2P file sharing allowed?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates allowance of P2P file sharing.

Account, Access & Management 10

Login History Visibility

Is login history visible?

Yes 1 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Shows login and access history.

It’s great that Proton lets you see your login history for better security insights. PIA not having this feature makes it less transparent in my opinion.

See more

Multi-User Profiles

Can multiple user profiles be created?

No 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Allows multiple user profiles under one account.

Access Control Levels

Are access control levels available?

No 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Supports different permission levels.

Session Management

Can active sessions be managed?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Allows viewing and managing active sessions.

User Account Dashboard

Is there a user account dashboard?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Provides a central interface for managing the account.

Sub-Account

Are sub-accounts supported?

No 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Allows creation of sub-accounts with limited access.

Team or Family Plans

Are team or family plans available?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates availability of shared plans.

Device Revocation

Can devices be revoked remotely?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Allows removal of connected devices remotely.

Password Policy

How strong is the password policy?

7 Proton 0 Votes Unspecified

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Strong

Rules for password complexity and security.

Two-Factor Authentication

Is two-factor authentication available?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Adds an extra layer of account security.

Customer Support & Documentation 8

Support Channels

What support channels are available?

72 Proton 0 Votes Live Chat, Email

61 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Live Chat, Email

Proton
Proton

Support channels include live chat and email, providing users with accessible options for customer assistance.

Lists available customer support channels.

Community Forum

Is there a community forum?

No 0 Votes Proton

Yes 1 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates presence of a user community forum.

PIA’s community forum is something I really like since it offers peer support beyond official channels, which Proton lacks.

See more

Knowledge Base

Is there a knowledge base?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates presence of a self-help knowledge base.

API Documentation

Is API documentation available?

No 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Provides documentation for API usage.

Response Time SLA

What is the response time SLA?

67 Proton 0 Votes Within 24 Hours

0 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Within 24 Hours

Expected support response time.

Support Language Coverage

What support languages are available?

25 Proton 0 Votes English, French, German, Spanish

36 Private Internet Access 0 Votes English

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

The support language coverage includes English, facilitating user interaction and support, with options for multiple other languages available.

Languages supported by customer service.

Setup Guides

Are setup guides available?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Provides step-by-step setup instructions.

Video Tutorials

Are video tutorials available?

No 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates availability of video-based tutorials.

Billing, Plans & Trials 12

Payment Methods Supported

What payment methods are supported?

57 Proton 0 Votes Credit Card, PayPal

41 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Credit Card, PayPal

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Payment methods supported include Credit Card and PayPal, facilitating convenient and popular payment options.

Supported payment methods.

Free Trial Availability

Is a free trial available?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates whether a free trial is offered.

Trial Duration

How long is the free trial?

30 days 0 Votes
Proton
0 days 0 Votes
Private Internet Access

Length of the free trial period.

Money-Back Guarantee

Is there a money-back guarantee?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates availability of a refund guarantee.

Business Plan Availability

Are business plans available?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates availability of business plans.

Subscription Length Options

What subscription lengths are available?

64 Proton 0 Votes Monthly, Yearly, Multi-Year

66 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Monthly, Yearly, Multi-Year

Proton
Proton

Subscription length options include monthly, yearly, and multi-year plans, offering flexibility for different user preferences.

Available subscription durations.

Refund Period

What is the refund period?

67 Proton 0 Votes 30 Days

0 Private Internet Access 0 Votes 30 Days

Proton
Proton

Offers a 30-day refund period, allowing users to request a refund within a month if unsatisfied.

Time window for requesting refunds.

Plan Change Policy

What is the plan change policy?

97 Proton 0 Votes Allowed Anytime

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Allowed Anytime

Proton
Proton

Plan change policy permits users to modify their subscription plans at any time without restrictions.

Policy governing whether users can upgrade or downgrade their subscription plans.

Anonymous Payment

Are anonymous payments supported?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Allows anonymous payment methods.

Auto-Renewal

Is auto-renewal enabled?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates whether subscriptions auto-renew.

Plan Flexibility

How flexible are the plans?

97 Proton 0 Votes High

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes High

Ease of changing plans.

Family Plan Availability

Are family plans available?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

No 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Indicates availability of family plans.

Reliability, Trust & Reputation 11

Public Reputation

What is the public reputation?

97 Proton 0 Votes Excellent

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Good

Proton
Proton

The VPN has an excellent public reputation, reflecting high user satisfaction and trust within the community.

Overall public perception.

Independent Security Audits

Are independent audits conducted?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Undergoes third-party security audits.

Audit Transparency

Are audit reports public?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Publishes full audit reports.

No-Log Claim Credibility

Is the no-logs claim credible?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Credibility of no-logs claims.

Third-Party Review Presence

Does the VPN have third-party reviews?

97 Proton 0 Votes Strong Presence

86 Private Internet Access 0 Votes Strong Presence

Proton
Proton

The VPN has a strong presence in third-party reviews, indicating robust scrutiny and generally positive reception.

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Third-party reviews show a strong presence, which suggests a good reputation and trust in the VPN service.

Indicates whether the VPN service is actively reviewed on independent third-party platforms.

Jurisdiction Clarity

Is jurisdiction clearly stated?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Jurisdiction clarity is maintained, enabling users to understand the legal framework governing the VPN's operations.

Clearly states legal jurisdiction.

Transparency Reports

Are transparency reports published?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access

Transparency reports are provided to increase accountability and inform users of any government requests or security matters.

Publishes government request reports.

Service Uptime

What is the service uptime?

99.9 % 0 Votes
Proton
99.9 % 0 Votes
Private Internet Access

Average service availability over time.

Downtime Transparency

Are downtimes disclosed?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Discloses outages and maintenance publicly.

Company Transparency

Is company ownership transparent?

Yes 0 Votes Proton

Yes 0 Votes Private Internet Access

Discloses ownership and leadership.

Surveys

Because hot takes deserve votes.

Performance

How would you rate the overall performance of this VPN?

Very fast — Under 2 hours
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Fast — 2 to 4 hours
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Average speed — 4 to 6 hours
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Slow — 6 to 10 hours
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Very slow — Over 10 hours
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access

Ease of Setup

How easy is it to set up this VPN?

Very easy — Takes under 5 minutes
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Easy — Takes 5 to 10 minutes
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Average — Takes 10 to 15 minutes
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Hard — Takes 15 to 30 minutes
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Very hard — Takes over 30 minutes
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access

User Interface

How would you describe the usability of this VPN's interface?

Very intuitive — Easy to navigate and use
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Easy to use — Clear and simple interface
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Average — Some features may be difficult to navigate
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Hard to use — Complex layout, hard to understand
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Very hard to use — Frustrating interface
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access

Connection Stability

How stable is the connection when using this VPN?

Very stable — Rare disconnections
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Stable — Occasional disconnections
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Average stability — Frequent minor disconnections
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Unstable — Regular disconnections
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Very unstable — Almost always disconnects
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access

Security Features

How would you rate the security features of this VPN?

Top-notch security — Includes features like 256-bit encryption, leak protection, and kill switch
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Great security — Includes strong encryption and basic protections
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Average security — Standard encryption, basic protections
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Weak security — Limited encryption and few protections
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Poor security — No encryption or protections
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access

Device Compatibility

How well does this VPN work across different devices?

Excellent compatibility — Works on all devices without issues
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Good compatibility — Works on most devices with few issues
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Average compatibility — Works on some devices, limited support
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Poor compatibility — Works only on specific devices
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Very limited compatibility — Works on very few devices
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access

Speed During Use

How fast is your internet connection when using this VPN?

Very fast — No noticeable decrease in speed
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Fast — Slight decrease in speed
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Average speed — Moderate decrease in speed
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Slow — Significant decrease in speed
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Very slow — Extremely slow, hard to use
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access

Customer Support

How would you rate the customer support for this VPN?

Exceptional — Quick responses, helpful solutions
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Good — Support is helpful and timely
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Average — Support is okay but may take some time
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Poor — Long wait times and incomplete solutions
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Very poor — No helpful support, slow responses
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access

Design Appeal

How would you rate the design appeal of this VPN's interface?

Very appealing — Modern, clean, and visually pleasing
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Appealing — Simple and easy on the eyes
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Average — Nothing special, functional but basic
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Unappealing — Outdated and unattractive
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Very unappealing — Difficult to look at
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access

Pricing

How would you rate the price of this VPN compared to its features?

Great value for money — Worth every penny
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Pretty good price — Good balance of features and cost
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Fair deal — Reasonable for the features provided
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Kinda pricey — Higher cost than expected
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access
Crazy expensive — Far too expensive for what it offers
0 Votes
Proton
0 Votes
Private Internet Access

Reviews 0

The good, the bad, and the brutally honest.

Average Rating

Proton
Proton
Proton
Proton
0 / 5 0 Reviews
Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access
0 / 5 0 Reviews

Discussions 0

Thoughts, takes, and hot debates.

Awards 0

Only the best made it here.

Collections 0

Treasures You’ve picked. No fluff, all fun.

More VPN 0

Unlock more awesome finds.

Other Proton VPN 0

Other Private Internet Access VPN 0

Proton
Proton
Proton
Proton
Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access
Private Internet Access
vs